• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Eatalia Pizza

Eatalia Pizza, located in Anaheim, CA, offers a variety of Italian pizzas and hot & cold sandwiches. Customers rave about the delicious BBQ chicken pizza, NY-style pies, and fresh salads. Despite its unassuming exterior, the restaurant surprises with its exceptional service and clean, welcoming interior. The menu features traditional New York-style pizza with a range of toppings, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality and flavor. Eatalia Pizza stands out for its convenient location, friendly staff, and affordable prices, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Eatalia Pizza – A Hidden Gem in Anaheim, CA

Located at 216 E Katella Ave in Anaheim, Eatalia Pizza is a must-visit for all pizza lovers. This Italian pizza joint offers a range of delicious options that cater to every palate. From hot and cold sandwiches to create-your-own pizzas, Eatalia Pizza has something for everyone.

Customers have raved about the quality of food and the overall dining experience at Eatalia Pizza. One reviewer, Jessica M., praised the BBQ chicken pizza, while William shared his positive experience with the NY-style pizza and fresh salads.

But what sets Eatalia Pizza apart is not just the food, but also the warm and friendly service. Tatania V. highlighted the convenience, friendliness, and affordability of this hidden gem. Garth R. appreciated the late-night option and the generous salad portions, while Jon R. enjoyed a post-Disneyland pizza hangout at Eatalia Pizza.

With a cozy atmosphere and a menu filled with mouth-watering options, Eatalia Pizza is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional New York slice or a customized pizza creation, Eatalia Pizza delivers on both taste and value.

Don't let the unassuming exterior fool you – step inside Eatalia Pizza and experience the true essence of delicious Italian pizza. With a dedication to quality ingredients and exceptional service, Eatalia Pizza truly shines in the bustling food scene of Anaheim.

So, if you find yourself craving a slice of authentic pizza or a satisfying sandwich, make your way to Eatalia Pizza and indulge in a culinary experience like no other.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Eatalia Pizza
Jessica M.
Jessica M.

It's a hole in the wall type shop but the food is delicious. We got the BBQ chicken pizza and made our own. Would definitely go back

William ..
William ..

My wife and I were staying at one of the many hotels within easy walking distance of this place. We were here on vacation and did not have a rental car. We did not want to walk a long distance to get to the chain restaurants within a half mile, so we ordered takeout from this place. I got a ten inch supreme NY-style pizza and my wife got spaghetti and a garden salad. I walked the short distance from our hotel to pick it up. It's kind of a hole in the wall in a dinky little strip mall, so my expectations were not high. Our food was ready the moment I walked in and the staff were very courteous. I got back to our room, and much to our surprise, the food was delicious. Folks, this is a SOLID NY-style pie. The crust was crisp on the, all the way to the center, and held up to the delicious toppings nicely. My wife's salad was amazing- the veggies were so fresh! The pasta was great as well. Our entire meal was just forty bucks! You can't get that kind of meal for this price in this area at this quality. If you need delivery or pickup in this area, this should be your go-to! Thanks, guys!

Tatania V.
Tatania V.

Our go to pizza so far... right across from our hotel. 2nd time visiting and ordered again from here. Thin crust pizza that taste soo good!! 5 out 5. Wings taste good, my preference will be a little more sauce please! 4 out 5. Price 5 out 5. Location, convenience, friendly 5 out 5.

Garth R.
Garth R.

I got the front window special one topping with pepperoni and garlic large. When I complained about paying almost 2 bucks for adding crushed garlic he threw it on for free. It was a little small for a medium but solid pizza given how late you can get a decent slice anywhere else that late and with what seemed like hand pressed crust. The crust and or sauce are lacking something that I cannot put my finger on but that would make it a five star taste. It's a small sit and eat with the family kind of place but typical old strip mall style shop with not so comfortable seating. Also got a salad for my daughter that she didn't eat and I ate it two days later. It was still crispy very large portion and delicious. Could be enough for two or three to share even though it came in what looked like a smaller container than expected for a large. It was packed full and tight with Romain, fresh grilled chicken, that had the grill marks on it, and had really good caesar dressing on the side. Even though it was very basic it hit the spot in more ways than one and I'll be back for more of it. Can't say anything really positive or negative about the staff. When pressed for answers to questions about the food, like does the salad have croutons it didn't seem like I was understood but it was late and maybe they were as tired and burned out as I was yet still making some decent food. Giving it four stars for being the best pizza place around open late. Comparing it to other fast food type pizza places it's three.

Jon R.
Jon R.

Late night pizza hangout after Disneyland! We stumbled upon this joint after checking out the liquor store next door. What more could you ask for? A freshly baked medium pepperoni pizza deal!!!! Definitely going here again!!!

Mathew G.
Mathew G.

Okay this is the definition of do not judge a book by its cover. When driving into the parking lot, it will not look like much. It is a very mediocre looking exterior in a gas station parking lot. However then you park and head inside. WOW! The inside is truly remarkable. Insanely clean and filled with a lot of tables to enjoy the pizza at the restaurant. Immediately when I walked in I was greeted with the friendliest hello I have ever received. It also amazed me with how quickly they managed to get the pizza baked and in my hands. Remarkable service! Now the big piece of this pie, how was the pizza? We all come to a pizza place for the food. Well this place serves traditional New York pizza. They offer by the slice, but when I went it was only cheese by the slice. Overall this is a great pizza. It is filled with some great flavors and toppings. Truly everyone needs to try this place! Parking is super easy here and I highly recommend visiting this gem!